Kea

Thanks for sharing those functions. Definitely cuts down on a lot of the boilerplate I see with Redux.

The concept expressed in the title matches a desire. Looking forward to checking out and hearing other's experiences.

I know it's just an example... But the Slider code is ridiculously overwrought. Building this type of image carousel is trivial with just plain HTML+CSS+JS. This example uses…

Just to clarify, I'm not picking on you; I realize it's hard to come up with meaningful examples. The problem with Slider is that it doesn't readily extrapolate into anything…

Looks pretty neat. My initial reactions: - I don't like the `@kea(...` because it's another bit of JS syntax I hadn't heard of before. Though I do like decorators in Python, I…

It's worth noting that both the React and Redux teams generally discourage the use of decorators. Quoting the Create-React-App README: > Create React App doesn’t support…

Looks pretty neat. My initial reactions: - I don't like the `@kea(...` because it's another bit of JS syntax I hadn't heard of before. Though I do like decorators in Python, I…

Hey, 1) As munchor pointed out, you don't need to use the decorators. See the "what is this @kea()" button in the first guide for more details: https://kea.js.org/guide/counter…

Is this type-safe? Can it infer the payload type somehow? With MobX you can write type-safe code, and it's pretty important in bigger code bases. Redux can be made type-safe but…

Hi, propTypes are supported as an (optional) first class citizen. Thus whatever is the output of a reducer or a selector, provided it is passed to a react component, is type…

I'm a big fan of decorators, but it seems like much of the React/Redux world is overly class-decorator happy. It's really common to define properties in a decorator which would…

> That said, the magic with having a big options hash in the `@kea({})` call itself is that then you can easily disconnect the logic from your components as your application…

Why not just use state, which seems like the correct solution to the examples?

If my favorite part of redux is structuring flows with redux-saga, does mobx-state-tree have a solution for me? For example, this is nice: ``` // On login, spin off the auth…

MST doesn't have the same restrictions as redux in terms of async so you don't need to do it in the same way. Edit: In MST it would look more like plain js: ``` class AuthStore()…

Shameless plug for another take on the same promise: https://github.com/jnorth/megalith I think most people who are attracted to Redux's core principals but want a more…

Looks nice. Seems to do a good job of making the code easy to read. I'm assuming you started this before mobx state tree? It looks very similar. After much experimentation, MST…

Shameless plug for another take on the same promise: https://github.com/jnorth/megalith I think most people who are attracted to Redux's core principals but want a more…

Looks nice, but I think I can get most of it using recompose, which I've been using extensively lately.

I’ve made a lightweight React library influenced by functional setState, and supports async/await/Promises, extracting values from DOM / forms easily, pure function actions,…

Also worth noting that the Redux docs _specifically_ have a section called "Reducing Boilerplate" [0] that shows how to write functions like this, and my Redux addons catalog [1]…