Graphite
Productivity
document editor
SHOW HN2018
How HN took it
6 positive, 30 neutral or asking, 1 mixed, 27 critical, out of 64 comments about the project. Thread score -0.37.
Idea: 1 for, 5 againstPrivacy: 1 for, 5 againstExecution: 1 for, 4 againstPerformance: 0 for, 2 againstPricing: 0 for, 2 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Open source and GPLv3 licensed
From 2 comments
The github link really needs to be on the main site. I do like that the whole thing is GPLv3. Not enough GPLv3 stuff out there these days, or even GPL in general.
djsumdog on HNI really like this a lot. I like the fact it gives choices, it's open source and the first implementation is really solid for an MVP. Well done. It's rather like a cross between…
jaggs on HN
Client-side encryption by default
From 1 comment
Good question. The primary difference is that your file data is encrypted client-side before it ever reaches the storage provider of your choice. And that data can only be…
jhunter1016 on HN
Objections
Spreadsheet and document features are limited
From 2 comments
Looks good, but as a google docs alternative? While the editor is fairly usable, the spreadsheet is very feature anaemic -- just enter data, export as CSV, insert/delete rows,…
hliyan on HNSpreadsheet and doc functionalities are very limited : you can't drag a formula, it just copies the value. You can't draw on a doc. It's more like a toy than a google doc…
julienfr112 on HN
Encryption is not documented clearly
From 1 comment
I see no mention anywhere, on Graphite or Blockstack, about how the encryption actually works. I’ve checked the following resources: * The Blockstack whitepaper:…
dsacco on HN
No real-time collaboration
From 1 comment
Cool concept, but note: I just tested this, and it is NOT a google docs alternative - it has no realtime sync (or at least, it wasn't working). I work extensively on…
marknadal on HN
Relies on the Bitcoin blockchain and is not truly decentralized
From 2 comments
This seems to rely specifically on the Bitcoin blockchain. From the Blockstack-Core node install instructions: "Because each Blockstack Core node maintains a full copy of the…
toyg on HNI believe this is only decentralized in intent and not actuality. This runs on top of Blockstack and after reading their Token whitepaper, particularly the section regarding the…
RobLach on HN
Name clashes with Graphite monitoring tool
From 2 comments
Graphite is an unfortunate name clash with graphite monitoring and metrics tools.
chillydawg on HNThis will easily be confused with Graphite the monitoring tool
lawnchair on HN
Requests
Mobile app support
From 2 comments
I really like this a lot. I like the fact it gives choices, it's open source and the first implementation is really solid for an MVP. Well done. It's rather like a cross between…
jaggs on HNAre there any plans for an Android App, or will it all be browser-based? Also where is the github/code located?
brokenmachine on HN
Comparison table with Word and Excel features
From 1 comment
The features page [0] has as much content about 'contacts' as it does docs or spreadsheets. Personally for me the most important thing is that it can do all that I use Word/Excel…
icc97 on HN
Self-hosting the frontend
From 1 comment
This looks quite interesting. For a full replacement I would require a presentation app though. Is there a planned option to selfhost the frontend for personal (and/or limited)…
zaarn on HN
Questions
How does encryption work in detail
From 2 comments
I see no mention anywhere, on Graphite or Blockstack, about how the encryption actually works. I’ve checked the following resources: * The Blockstack whitepaper:…
dsacco on HNI'm on the engineering team at Blockstack, and wrote the client-side encryption functions used by applications. I totally agree with the idea that if software uses encryption, it…
ablankst on HN
Is the project open source
From 2 comments
Sign in button does nothing on iOS 11. Also, is the project open source? Otherwise there is less appeal even though it is decentralized.
bringtheaction on HNI believe this is only decentralized in intent and not actuality. This runs on top of Blockstack and after reading their Token whitepaper, particularly the section regarding the…
RobLach on HN
What is Blockstack
From 1 comment
What is Blockstack, in clear English?
fiatjaf on HN
Alternatives named
Dropbox with local files and PGP
From 1 comment
how does this differ from local documents combined with dropbox?
icc97 on HN
Airborn OS
From 1 comment
Important note, a project that you need to look at if you are looking for a similar thing: Airbornos. It has about the same general premise, but is even more secure in some…
Erlich_Bachman on HN
Etherpad and Framapad
From 1 comment
Thanks. Unless I'm missing something, Framapad and Etherpad are centralized services. Graphite is decentralized.
jhunter1016 on HN