my holiday project
Productivity
image blogging
SHOW HN2011
22points
26comments
#466of 1,097 in 2011
Top 43%of 2011 by points
How HN took it
DebatedReal support and real criticism
4 positive, 5 neutral or asking, 3 mixed, 4 critical, out of 16 comments about the project. Thread score +0.08.
Privacy: 0 for, 2 againstIdea: 2 for, 0 againstDesign: 0 for, 2 againstExecution: 2 for, 0 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Simple design and clean execution
From 4 comments
Wow, this might be one of the best and most promising projects I've seen here on HN. I like the design and the simplicity and I can really see me using it. Good luck with the…
malte on HNThis is just beautiful. Love idea, love design, love execution :) Keep working on it and good luck!
domagoj on HNReally nice idea and execution, well done! I already have a list growing in my head of friends who'll love this. BTW a small but prominent typo: "beatiful" on the front page.
oops on HNI like this a lot and the barrier to entry is really low. Plus the simple design is a major plus. What's a big negative to me is the design of my feed. It's actually what's…
jamesteow on HN
Low barrier to entry
From 1 comment
I like this a lot and the barrier to entry is really low. Plus the simple design is a major plus. What's a big negative to me is the design of my feed. It's actually what's…
jamesteow on HN
Objections
Feed layout and sort control take too much space
From 1 comment
I like this a lot and the barrier to entry is really low. Plus the simple design is a major plus. What's a big negative to me is the design of my feed. It's actually what's…
jamesteow on HN
Image copyright concerns with reposted images
From 1 comment
Clickable: http://thingsand.me/ Looks very nice and I can see a few ideas to monetize this. Is the directory "empty" because it's a new service or is there a limit to the number…
pierrefar on HN
Security issues: file upload trusts extension, GET-based deletion vulnerable to CSRF
From 1 comment
A little security tip: http://thingsand.me/media/images/image_228.html Your uploader is blindly trusting the file extension for an image being uploaded. It's possible to upload…
nbpoole on HN
Requests
Add an API or iPhone uploader
From 1 comment
Add basic image editing tools
From 1 comment
Clickable: http://thingsand.me/ Looks very nice and I can see a few ideas to monetize this. Is the directory "empty" because it's a new service or is there a limit to the number…
pierrefar on HN
Facebook app integration
From 1 comment
Also. A Facebook app would be good so people who decide to upload their photos to your website can still make them available within Facebook to their friends. Most people aren't…
grepular on HN
In-page screenshot capture
From 1 comment
Pretty badass. I might be crazy for suggesting this for this idea(as this is pretty off) but it'd be terrific if I could take a snapshot of a page. For instance, I run the tool,…
hajrice on HN
Questions
How is it different from Posterous or Tumblr?
From 1 comment
Hey, just checked it out. Awesome stuff, but what's the difference between this one and Posterous, or Tumblr?
lightyoruichi on HN
Will custom domains be supported?
From 1 comment
Do you know about or are you influenced by: ffffound.com ? Great site. Keeping it (or having an option to style it) VERY bare bones like that would be awesome. Also, think about…
pkamb on HN
Is the directory empty or limited?
From 1 comment
Clickable: http://thingsand.me/ Looks very nice and I can see a few ideas to monetize this. Is the directory "empty" because it's a new service or is there a limit to the number…
pierrefar on HN
Alternatives named
Tumblr
From 2 comments
Hey, just checked it out. Awesome stuff, but what's the difference between this one and Posterous, or Tumblr?
lightyoruichi on HNDo you know about or are you influenced by: ffffound.com ? Great site. Keeping it (or having an option to style it) VERY bare bones like that would be awesome. Also, think about…
pkamb on HN
Posterous
From 2 comments
Hey, just checked it out. Awesome stuff, but what's the difference between this one and Posterous, or Tumblr?
lightyoruichi on HNClickable: http://thingsand.me/ Looks very nice and I can see a few ideas to monetize this. Is the directory "empty" because it's a new service or is there a limit to the number…
pierrefar on HN
ffffound
From 1 comment
Do you know about or are you influenced by: ffffound.com ? Great site. Keeping it (or having an option to style it) VERY bare bones like that would be awesome. Also, think about…
pkamb on HN
weheartit
From 1 comment
In case you didn't know, weheartit.com's extension symbol is a heart. Might be confusing for users of both services.
tulensrma on HN