paid link to
Web and SaaS
paid link payments
SHOW HN2022
How HN took it
25 positive, 54 neutral or asking, 7 mixed, 43 critical, out of 129 comments about the project. Thread score -0.11.
Idea: 23 for, 23 againstExecution: 0 for, 6 againstDesign: 1 for, 3 againstDocs: 0 for, 4 againstPrivacy: 0 for, 4 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Simple, clean concept with clear value for selling one-off access.
From 3 comments
You kidding me? You're a complainer in search of an issue, there's nothing wrong with this. "Buying things on the internet" obviously works already, in the form of patreon,…
sdwr on HNThis is a good idea. Very simple.
miiiiiike on HNAwesome idea!
terpimost on HN
Gumroad-style idea seen as timely.
From 2 comments
I'm surprised to see the concerns from other comments. Isn't this exactly how Gumroad started too right here on HN?
vyrotek on HNRight timing of launch if we consider Gumroad's price increament.
ms7892 on HN
Objections
Paid links can be shared after payment, bypassing the paywall.
From 3 comments
I like this idea but wouldn't it be really easy to bypass? Once you pay for it, I imagine you get redirected and can just share the final URL destination for free.
tendiesfortwo on HNBut couldn't people just share the link after the redirect?
ezekg on HNThat's exactly right. This service wouldn't be appropriate if you were trying to protect access to (for example) a full web application. It could be appropriate if you were…
neptuneis on HN
Anyone can create a paid link to someone else's URL, enabling scams and fake links.
From 3 comments
The issue is I as a scammer can create a paid link to any arbitrary URL, including your URL. There's no verification of control like how say LetsEncrypt works. As a user I'm…
giantrobot on HNhow will this be abuse proof? scenario: You share a link with me, earn $0.50, i notice people willing to pay for it. I then go on to create my own link once I have access to the…
Justsignedup on HNgoldmine for fake links? does it check ownership?
lx0741 on HN
No preview or seller branding, so buyers don't know what they pay for.
From 3 comments
I'm not convinced this isn't a solution in search of a problem. What is it good for? For most things being sold you'll want an account attached. If this is a song or a book then…
dale_glass on HNSince it's something that already happens and it's a known issue, it's pretty ridiculous a brand new project doesn't have some mechanism in place to prevent it. Something as…
giantrobot on HNThis is an amazing product & given that gumroad has recently increased prices, the timing could not have been better. But information architecture of the landing page needs to…
ujnproduct on HN
Chargeback and stolen card risk.
From 2 comments
How does this handle chargebacks? What is to stop someone from putting in a bunch of stolen credit cards?
paulpauper on HNIf someone hypothetically did a chargeback, who would have to pay the ~$15 dispute fee? You or the user that created the link?
doerig on HN
Landing page design looks untrustworthy.
From 2 comments
Quick and blunt piece of advice: you need to redesign your website asap imo. It reminds me exactly of what a webpage looks like once the hosting has expired on it. Very low trust…
Deegy on HNI think there was a link-shortener back in the day (when people used link-shorteners) that did this. The exact same way. I can't remember what happened to them... if they went…
dbg31415 on HN
Requests
Add PayPal or other payment options.
From 2 comments
Looks awesome, with just a few issues. One is that I don't see PayPal support. Typing credit card info into any site not owned by a billion dollar company is a bit scary.…
eternityforest on HNHey I am wondering if paypal payment can be added later or is there an alter service using paypal gateway?
terrycody on HN
Show an example paid link or preview of the buyer experience.
From 2 comments
Would be useful to have an example paidlink so you can see what the UX is like for visitors.
pimlottc on HNGod damn it. I really wanted to see what your paywall looked like but got hit with "hey signup. hey link your stripe". Show me an example.
David_Axelrod on HN
Add crypto payment support.
From 2 comments
I would use this if it had stable coin support like USDC. Please add something like that or just BTC. Also, that way we would not need to setup a stripe account.
max_ on HNI'd like to have this but for XMR payments.
the-anarchist on HN
Provide an API for creating paid links.
From 1 comment
Christ, this is genius. Why doesn't this already exist? I can already think of a bunch of use cases. You should definitely work on getting an API together. I could see people…
kypro on HN
Questions
How does the seller receive money and what are the fees?
From 3 comments
so OK. How do I, the publisher, get my money? A FAQ would be nice.
99failures on HNAnyone able to comment on what fees they’re charging and onboarding process? So far for the onboarding process I have: - signup by giving email and password; does not appear to…
O__________O on HNThis is an amazing product & given that gumroad has recently increased prices, the timing could not have been better. But information architecture of the landing page needs to…
ujnproduct on HN
How are chargebacks and disputes handled?
From 2 comments
If someone hypothetically did a chargeback, who would have to pay the ~$15 dispute fee? You or the user that created the link?
doerig on HNHow does this handle chargebacks? What is to stop someone from putting in a bunch of stolen credit cards?
paulpauper on HN
Does the link check the destination URL and ownership?
From 2 comments
It would be a plus if paidlink.to actually made a call to the link before accepting payment, and put up a warning / stopped the transaction if it didn't get a 200, "We're sorry…
blacksmith_tb on HNgoldmine for fake links? does it check ownership?
lx0741 on HN
Alternatives named
Stripe payment links
From 1 comment
Cool idea, but it'd be great to add an explanation for choosing this over Stripe payment links (https://stripe.com/payments/payment-links). For Stripe, you can configure a…
levpopov on HN
Gumroad
From 2 comments
I'm surprised to see the concerns from other comments. Isn't this exactly how Gumroad started too right here on HN?
vyrotek on HNThis is an amazing product & given that gumroad has recently increased prices, the timing could not have been better. But information architecture of the landing page needs to…
ujnproduct on HN
Easy Digital Downloads for WordPress
From 1 comment
If you want this functionality on a WordPress-powered site, which is one of the use cases stated, this is the industry standard way of doing this within the WP world:…
dotBen on HN
Adfly
From 2 comments
This is absolutely nothing new. Adfly (adf.ly) was the popular version of this 10 years ago. Often modders would put their mediafire links behind adfly to get a little revenue.
rozab on HNSo this is like AdFly?
Alifatisk on HN
Monetized.Link
From 1 comment
I created a similar service to this called Monetized.Link https://www.monetized.link/ ...We describe it as if you put together a tiny url and a paywall. From what I've seen…
mankins on HN