Postcardbot
Consumer and social
postcard sending
SHOW HN2023
How HN took it
12 positive, 31 neutral or asking, 2 mixed, 9 critical, out of 54 comments about the project. Thread score +0.04.
Idea: 8 for, 1 againstDesign: 3 for, 3 againstExecution: 0 for, 2 againstPricing: 1 for, 1 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Simple, low-friction texting interface
From 2 comments
I gave this a spin and sent a few cards. It was great, very low friction and easy to use. In the age of ChatGPT showing how easy a chat interface CAN be this seem really on point.
duxup on HNThe US is a big market. And is the most likely country that people will be able to send to. So it’s a great place to start. I use voip accounts and have been able to send to…
prepend on HN
Fun, quirky indie project
From 2 comments
As a side note I must confess a certain degree of uneasiness reading some of the borderline-toxic comments, which - to be fair - are nothing new. This time around though it seems…
naetius on HNAbsolutely. This project is super cool!! I'll likely use this to send a postcard to some friends. Such a cool little website to start and it feels so indie!
madelyn on HN
Objections
Requires a US phone number, unusable elsewhere
From 2 comments
Nice idea, but the fact that it requires sending to a US-specific phone number makes it unusable for most of the world. For me, the ideal implementation of this would be a simple…
ludwik on HNI'm in Europe with an iPhone and this didn't work, but I'd like to try it. [edit: telegram integration would be quite cool.]
bravura on HN
Unclear how mass abuse would be moderated
From 1 comment
Have you though about how malevolent people will abuse this? E.g. sending a pic from a shocksite to someone you don't like? You'd have to set up a content moderation department…
amelius on HN
Unit economics seem thin
From 1 comment
The biz case here is interesting: I had no idea what the postage rates are from the US, so checked and saw that they start at $1.45. Maybe you can get bulk rates from the USPS…
Jun8 on HN
Requests
WhatsApp or Telegram integration
From 3 comments
Is MMS compression an issue? I typically never text photos from my android and instead rely on WhatsApp so they don't get compressed
arjvik on HNI'm in Europe with an iPhone and this didn't work, but I'd like to try it. [edit: telegram integration would be quite cool.]
bravura on HNI think that's addressed in the FAQ: > Currently, we only have a US based phone number that can be used to interact with our service. We understand that this can be expensive in…
naetius on HN
vCard contact add link
From 2 comments
You should add a ‘tap to add to Contacts’ link - I think a vCard would work? I don’t want to send a postcard right now, but I’d definitely like to store the number for later use.…
jrmg on HNI don’t have much time so excuse my brevity, but: I love the idea. It’s simple, it’s solves a user problem. You can explain it in 1-2 sentences. Setup = adding your number to the…
rpastuszak on HN
Postcard templates
From 1 comment
I think it’d be a neat value-add if there were some (optional) postcard templates. Stuff like “Greetings from scenic <location_name>” that could either be used seriously or…
ytdytvhxgydvhh on HN
Package pricing for bulk sends
From 1 comment
This is awesome! May I recommend a package deal? For example, I want to send to a bunch of friends, maybe a different price point for larger orders (if feasible)? $10/4-5 for…
sodality2 on HN
Questions
Does MMS compress photos?
From 2 comments
Is MMS compression an issue? I typically never text photos from my android and instead rely on WhatsApp so they don't get compressed
arjvik on HNIs the resolution of MMS high enough to make a good postcard?
schemescape on HN
Is it charged per message or subscription?
From 1 comment
>STOP to unsubscribe Confused. Is this charged per shot or subscription?!?
Havoc on HN
Alternatives named
Czech Post and Swiss Post postcard apps
From 2 comments
Czech Post has an app that does. Local price is like a $1. It works worldwide regular international price.
pixel3234 on HNSwitzerland has it too, since a long time. https://www.post.ch/en/sending-letters/sending-letters/postcard-creator-app
_trampeltier on HN
Fizzer
From 1 comment
https://www.fizzer.com does the same, and it's quite nice to use.
mike31fr on HN
Photowire and merci-facteur
From 2 comments
UK is private enterprise rather than Royal Mail https://www.photowire.uk/ One example I just found. £2 to address in UK and £3 international. A thought has crossed my mind: if…
2b3a51 on HNSeems to cost €2 internationally on this french website : https://www.merci-facteur.com/tarifs.php
croisillon on HN