Linkwarden
Productivity
bookmark manager
SHOW HN2023
280points
88comments
#171of 3,109 in 2023
Top 6%of 2023 by points
How HN took it
CuriousMostly questions and neutral comments
8 positive, 27 neutral or asking, 2 mixed, 6 critical, out of 43 comments about the project. Thread score +0.04.
Idea: 5 for, 1 againstPerformance: 1 for, 1 againstDocs: 0 for, 2 againstDesign: 0 for, 1 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Clean, neat design and useful self-hostable open source tool
From 4 comments
This looks really nice, great work. I'll definitely give it a try. Have you considered a free tier where you could monetize it maybe via sponsorships/ads with the goal to have a…
swozey on HNAmazing. Collaborative bookmark management needed to happen. Imagine deciding you want to learn a new skill and not having to start from square one learning the lay of the land…
totalconfusion on HNLooks really clean. A few questions: - It’s not clear if this saves highlight in Ng and annotations (notes about the highlights). More than saving a bookmark we think about a…
j45 on HNI like to save the best / most interesting links I come across as I browse the web. It can come in handy to pull up a blog post I read a while ago or remember some new sass…
andrewrothman on HN
Good for curating shared resource collections
From 2 comments
Amazing. Collaborative bookmark management needed to happen. Imagine deciding you want to learn a new skill and not having to start from square one learning the lay of the land…
totalconfusion on HNThis looks really nice, great work. I'll definitely give it a try. Have you considered a free tier where you could monetize it maybe via sponsorships/ads with the goal to have a…
swozey on HN
Objections
Self-hosting may be heavy; Prisma/Next builds struggle on small machines
From 2 comments
Oof, any time I see next/prisma I already know that my tiny VPS will likely choke building this... So yeah, self-hostable, but not for everyone. Got burned with this by cal.com…
vsviridov on HNI threw together a quick docker-compose.yml to try this out. For anyone else that wants to spin this up and give it a try locally:…
joekrill on HN
No export functionality
From 1 comment
To save anyone else the clicks, the pricing is $4/month for unlimited links. Currently, no export functionality.
bachmeier on HN
Documentation page not found
From 1 comment
Where's the documentation? I get page not found eror
trinsic2 on HN
Requests
Full-text search of saved pages
From 2 comments
Are there full-text-search capabilities?
RevoGen on HNIn addition to PDF and PNG, died it store searchable text from the page. If really live a way to do a text search of my bookmarks.
asielen on HN
Automatic submission to archive.org
From 1 comment
I've used Raindrop[1] for the last few years and it works well - cross device support, archived pages, and tags/folders. Going to check out Linkwarden since I really like the…
ecliptik on HN
Docker version
From 1 comment
When will docker version arrive?
efff on HN
Freemium or free tier
From 2 comments
This looks really nice, great work. I'll definitely give it a try. Have you considered a free tier where you could monetize it maybe via sponsorships/ads with the goal to have a…
swozey on HNAmazing. Collaborative bookmark management needed to happen. Imagine deciding you want to learn a new skill and not having to start from square one learning the lay of the land…
totalconfusion on HN
Questions
Support for LDAP/OAuth2 authentication
From 1 comment
I'll definitely give it a short this weekend. Are there any plans to support different authentication methods? Like LDAP, OAuth2 etc? I'm using linkding at the moment…
pratio on HN
Monetization and plans for self-hosted version
From 1 comment
This looks really neat! Can you share more about the project? Such as: 1. What is the driving vision behind this project? For example is this just scratching a personal itch with…
freedomben on HN
Safari or iOS app support
From 1 comment
Is the browser extension coming for Safari as well? And what about an iOS App?
Hiko0 on HN
Alternatives named
Floccus
From 1 comment
Not to diminish the effort here, but I just want to point out (as someone who has tried lots of bookmark managers) that Floccus is everything I want from a bookmark manager…
janvdberg on HN
Raindrop.io
From 2 comments
I've used Raindrop[1] for the last few years and it works well - cross device support, archived pages, and tags/folders. Going to check out Linkwarden since I really like the…
ecliptik on HNI like to save the best / most interesting links I come across as I browse the web. It can come in handy to pull up a blog post I read a while ago or remember some new sass…
andrewrothman on HN
ArchiveBox
From 2 comments
I've used Raindrop[1] for the last few years and it works well - cross device support, archived pages, and tags/folders. Going to check out Linkwarden since I really like the…
ecliptik on HNThis looks slick. Because archive.org is getting a little problematic by not allowing more sites to be archived, decentralized archiving is becoming more important. I have been…
kornhole on HN
linkding
From 1 comment
I'll definitely give it a short this weekend. Are there any plans to support different authentication methods? Like LDAP, OAuth2 etc? I'm using linkding at the moment…
pratio on HN
Shiori
From 1 comment
eeeeh. Shiori looks like it'd work infinitely better compared to floccus. It has an extension, tags, and everything is stored in a central repository you can visit from web (or…
lannisterstark on HN