Fill
Creative
generative image editing
SHOW HN2023
How HN took it
4 positive, 24 neutral or asking, 4 mixed, 14 critical, out of 46 comments about the project. Thread score -0.13.
Execution: 1 for, 5 againstIdea: 1 for, 3 againstDesign: 1 for, 3 againstPerformance: 0 for, 1 againstPrivacy: 0 for, 1 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Results look realistic and impressive
From 3 comments
Amazing! The inserted objects are renders of textured 3D models and not generated by a diffusion model + ControlNet? Is there a fixed set of textured 3D models available or are…
reichardt on HNBetween Fill3D's architecture that 'path traces to render ultra-realistic results' and fxn.ai transparent deployment capability... I gotta say this is super impressive work. I…
bsenftner on HNThe demo looks amazing! Congrats for your first show HN. Quick question on the technical side, do you generate the (added) objects in 3D directly or generate them in 2D and…
sourabh03agr on HN
Good first Show HN
From 1 comment
Pretty awesome for first Show HN. Multimodal search is very fascinating. I am using SDXL + LoRa model over here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37696033
tinytera on HN
Objections
Enables fake real estate listing photos
From 2 comments
I am impressed by the tech, but appalled by the possibilities. Where I live, it is already common practice for real estate 'agents' to photoshop the properties listed for sale to…
LeonM on HNLive the project, great work! can you think about adding some ethical clauses to your license. Something to allow people to use it for good wholesome purposes, but to avoid…
kderbyma on HN
Limited fixed catalog of about 300 models
From 1 comment
What bugs did you encounter? And yes, because we're using actual 3D models, there's a fixed set of models (right now, just under 300). Because the priority is ultra-realism, the…
olokobayusuf on HN
Cloud-only processing raises privacy concerns
From 1 comment
It looks like a cloud-only app. If it doesn't run entirely locally, it's useless to me. Shipping my data to an external data processor is a security risk I'm not allowed to take.
philipov on HN
Generation failed for some objects
From 1 comment
Really can't generate the object I need to place. Few that don't work 1. terrarium 2. fish tank 3. bunk bed
frozenport on HN
Requests
Gallery of more examples
From 1 comment
The example looks very good. Do you have more images to share? I think more examples would be nice to show off more of what it can handle. Different room types, interiors etc.…
matsemann on HN
Remove objects from images
From 1 comment
Is there any way to remove objects from an initial image, so that then it can be utilized for staging?
aantix on HN
Support for decks, porches and landscaping
From 2 comments
Will it work with decks and porches? I have images of decks and porches that need staging for the construction company's web site.
qingcharles on HN> virtual staging in real estate media If you can make this work with exteriors, Landscaping design is huge. Maybe start with something simple like desert landscaping (which is…
ralfhn on HN
Free tier for testing
From 1 comment
I like it, but should have added some free tier to test it out.
tamimio on HN
Questions
How deprojection works
From 1 comment
Could you speak more to the "deprojection" step? What is that?
blovescoffee on HN
Business model and pricing
From 2 comments
What are you thinking is your business model? I'm a sysadmin at a small MLS, trying to figure out where we'd integrate it. At $2/stage it's something we'd probably have to have…
linsomniac on HNWow, nice. I hope you charge realtors a fat price for this
artursapek on HN
Works on non-room images
From 1 comment
Nice! Like your landing page. How well does it work on non-room images?
prashp on HN
Alternatives named
InteriorAI
From 2 comments
- The maker's post
Decorify from Wayfair is also using diffusion, same as the other folks who have built similar things in the market (InteriorAI is probably leading product here). We'll see where…
olokobayusuf on HN
Wayfair Decorify
From 1 comment
You realise this is the role of entire teams at certain companies right? If you automate enough parts you'd do able to automate the work of 30 people per company doing this. Not…
moritonal on HN
Adobe Firefly
From 1 comment
Virtual staging photoshop
From 1 comment
They've had staging photoshop forever.
smrtinsert on HN