ytch
Consumer and social
video streaming
SHOW HN2024
How HN took it
148 positive, 132 neutral or asking, 6 mixed, 23 critical, out of 309 comments about the project. Thread score +0.44.
Idea: 74 for, 8 againstDesign: 23 for, 9 againstExecution: 13 for, 4 againstPerformance: 2 for, 0 againstDocs: 1 for, 0 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Captures the feel of channel surfing and nostalgia
From 4 comments
This is neat! Feels just like old cable, the static transitions being a good touch.
racefan76 on HNGoodness. I never realized how nostalgic it would feel to flip channels. Your project took me all the way back to being a kid in the 90s and clicking through channels on the TV…
jodacola on HNthis is phenomenal, i love it, it genuinely feels like flipping TV channels. really excellent work!
93po on HNAre we going full circle from TV to streaming back to TV? Probably not, but I do really enjoy the discovery aspect as well as reducing the overwhelming options of streaming down…
milanhbs on HN
Smooth, well-polished execution
From 3 comments
This is great, really smooth
hdlothia on HNThis is cool and really well done, I'm kinda blown away. Would love to hear from the creator on what inspired them and how they designed and made it retro yet also minimal and so…
metadat on HNAre we going full circle from TV to streaming back to TV? Probably not, but I do really enjoy the discovery aspect as well as reducing the overwhelming options of streaming down…
milanhbs on HN
Content discovery without endless choice
From 3 comments
Well done. My team built this at Disney six years ago when we were trying to solve content discovery problems. The problem with endless carousels of thumbnails is that it really…
madrox on HNThis is something I always wonder... Something that I really miss from TV on internet content (YouTube, movie streamings and so on) is turn it on and watching what's being…
lucasoshiro on HNOne thing about analog interfaces is that they are really in a way empowering to the User. Don't like what you're seeing? Just one button press or the turn of a tuner dial and…
atoav on HN
Objections
Cannot pause or rewind, so content is missed
From 3 comments
The best part of this is the channel doesn't pause when you flip away from it. It is always "running" and if you flip away you will miss it. That builds in a FOMO trade-off which…
tantalor on HNThis hooked me right away! I wish it had pause though because I discovered a show I wanted to watch and had to work. :(
georgeecollins on HNThis blew my mind, it's such a different experience. Currently watching the music channel (8, The Lumineers - Full Performance (Live on KEXP)). Since the author is reading here,…
qwertox on HN
Static between channels is unpleasant
From 3 comments
Awesome! But please remove the static fuzz it's really unpleasant.
frabjoused on HNThis is great, but the static doesn't seem random? It just bugged me a tiny bit. Otherwise, I love this.
stavros on HNNeed a larger "static" sprite so it's not obviously a sprite.
gowld on HN
Missing volume control and mono audio
From 2 comments
I'd echo the sentiment that this is amazing, and that a TV guide would be awesome. I'd also suggest maybe adding the channel names (like the comment you posted here) to the app…
slazaro on HNThis blew my mind, it's such a different experience. Currently watching the music channel (8, The Lumineers - Full Performance (Live on KEXP)). Since the author is reading here,…
qwertox on HN
Requests
Pause or timeshift
From 2 comments
This hooked me right away! I wish it had pause though because I discovered a show I wanted to watch and had to work. :(
georgeecollins on HNThis blew my mind, it's such a different experience. Currently watching the music channel (8, The Lumineers - Full Performance (Live on KEXP)). Since the author is reading here,…
qwertox on HN
Customizable channels and schedules
From 2 comments
This is perfect. Can it be customized (with custom channels and schedules)? I was looking for exactly this to control my (and my kid's) TV habbits. My TV is only for YouTube.…
smusamashah on HNI’d love something like this where I can configure channels to have podcasts, music, movies and it all streams to my tv. Is there something like this? I’ve heard of other users…
yadaeno on HN
TV guide listing schedules
From 3 comments
Now we need a TV Guide.
whoiscroberts on HNYou should make the channels change the video they're playing on a schedule, and link to a tv guide listing that shows the schedule.
DougWebb on HNThis is cool and really well done, I'm kinda blown away. Would love to hear from the creator on what inspired them and how they designed and made it retro yet also minimal and so…
metadat on HN
Keyboard channel up/down mapping
From 1 comment
I have an extra suggestion: Maybe some keyboard key mapping, like up/down for switching the channel. I'm imagining having this perma-running in a small PC connected to a TV and…
slazaro on HN
Disable static effect
From 1 comment
How do I disable the static effect between channel changes?
lagniappe on HN
Questions
What is the source of the content and how are videos chosen
From 3 comments
This is simply awesome, but apologies, I don't follow, what's the source for all the content?
tumidpandora on HNThis is awesome! How are the videos being chosen? Without any monetization, I guess we shouldn't expect anything more than a loop of the same videos, right?
lukas099 on HNIt seems like random videos are being played from many years ago and/or getting live feeds of some stations. Does everyone get the same selection of channel feeds?
nashashmi on HN
Is the source code open
From 2 comments
Is there an open source code repo for this?
theginger on HNSource https://github.com/stevemk14ebr/YTCH
supernihil on HN
Are content creators compensated
From 1 comment
This is super fun, but I hope the content creators are being compensated. Content creators work hard to produce this content under the assumption they will be paid for it (in one…
TechSquidTV on HN
Alternatives named
80s.myretrotvs.com retro TV site
From 1 comment
Just like https://80s.myretrotvs.com/
domatic1 on HN
Pluto TV
From 1 comment
I worked at Pluto TV pre-launch, and YouTube "live" crammed into channels was basically our app, with a scheduler system that allowed us to also render a channel guide.
jondwillis on HN