Good Films graph
Consumer and social
film ratings
SHOW HN2012
77points
16comments
#309of 1,677 in 2012
Top 19%of 2012 by points
How HN took it
LovedMost comments that take a side are positive
7 positive, 3 neutral or asking, 2 mixed, 1 critical, out of 13 comments about the project. Thread score +0.44.
Idea: 4 for, 0 againstDesign: 1 for, 1 againstExecution: 2 for, 0 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Clean, well-executed design
From 3 comments
I just have to say that I think your execution is exceptional. Everything is so clearly laid out, your design is great. Even though I didn't understand the x/y axis of how you…
pedalpete on HNTop notch design and execution! Just love the discovery line/zoom feature, very unique and useful. Minor issues: - How are the hearts calculated? - The graph is too crowded, I…
fuzzythinker on HNExcellent work.
pointlessjon on HN
Outlier films and discovery are interesting
From 2 comments
Love looking at the outliers - particularly "The Room" over on the top left corner!
minikomi on HNVery cool, make searching for things like "Highest rated, lowest re-watchable" fun and interesting. On a side-note. In the above query one of the front-runners seems to be "Grave…
rurounijones on HN
Objections
Graph is crowded and axes are unexplained
From 3 comments
Top notch design and execution! Just love the discovery line/zoom feature, very unique and useful. Minor issues: - How are the hearts calculated? - The graph is too crowded, I…
fuzzythinker on HNThis is pretty awesome. Couple things: 1) Clicking on tabs in the graph causes you to snap to the top of the page. Adding return false; to your tab/link handler will fix that. 2)…
caffeineninja on HNI just have to say that I think your execution is exceptional. Everything is so clearly laid out, your design is great. Even though I didn't understand the x/y axis of how you…
pedalpete on HN
Clicking tabs jumps page to top and lines are unclear
From 2 comments
This is pretty awesome. Couple things: 1) Clicking on tabs in the graph causes you to snap to the top of the page. Adding return false; to your tab/link handler will fix that. 2)…
caffeineninja on HNIs there any reason for this? Clicking on the Princess Bride links me to Ep6, Lost Ark, Avengers and BTTF. To me it implies that they're related or similar. But I can't see any…
xlevus on HN
Requests
Colour or filter by genre
From 2 comments
If you have the data, it would be cool to see this colorized by genre and length. My guess is that dramas have a higher quality to rewatchability ratio than comedies, and that a…
paulgb on HNTop notch design and execution! Just love the discovery line/zoom feature, very unique and useful. Minor issues: - How are the hearts calculated? - The graph is too crowded, I…
fuzzythinker on HN
Zoom and pan
From 1 comment
This is pretty awesome. Couple things: 1) Clicking on tabs in the graph causes you to snap to the top of the page. Adding return false; to your tab/link handler will fix that. 2)…
caffeineninja on HN
Better related-films matching and search highlighting
From 1 comment
Top notch design and execution! Just love the discovery line/zoom feature, very unique and useful. Minor issues: - How are the hearts calculated? - The graph is too crowded, I…
fuzzythinker on HN
Questions
How are the hearts calculated?
From 1 comment
Top notch design and execution! Just love the discovery line/zoom feature, very unique and useful. Minor issues: - How are the hearts calculated? - The graph is too crowded, I…
fuzzythinker on HN
What do the lines mean?
From 2 comments
This is pretty awesome. Couple things: 1) Clicking on tabs in the graph causes you to snap to the top of the page. Adding return false; to your tab/link handler will fix that. 2)…
caffeineninja on HNIs there any reason for this? Clicking on the Princess Bride links me to Ep6, Lost Ark, Avengers and BTTF. To me it implies that they're related or similar. But I can't see any…
xlevus on HN