Forking Recipes
Consumer and social
recipe sharing
SHOW HN2013
How HN took it
18 positive, 20 neutral or asking, 8 mixed, 9 critical, out of 55 comments about the project. Thread score +0.18.
Idea: 12 for, 3 againstDesign: 5 for, 5 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Good idea applying forking to recipes
From 3 comments
Great idea! It seems obvious in hindsight, at least to people who understand forking and dvcs. Which is great. Let's see how non-tech people are able to understand and use such…
nullspace on HNNeat. When I saw the headline I thought that this would be too technical to get traction with non-geeks but it looks nice and I could see it becoming popular especially with…
kristiandupont on HNGreat idea. Needs a better app and UX but really good idea. Good job!
vinrob on HN
Recipe discovery and layout are easy to use
From 1 comment
I like how easy recipe discovery is on forkingrecipes. I think the waterfall layout and search bar were good decisions. Mappum and I made something pretty similar for the last…
kepzorz on HN
Objections
The word fork is confusing for non-developers
From 2 comments
You need to hire a designer for this. Cooking/recipes/food markets are really visually driven. You also need to define what a fork is right on the landing page. A fork for a cook…
orangethirty on HNI'd like to second this, and also say that you should really work hard to establish "fork" and "forking" in contexts that make sense to non-developers. They're second nature for…
cheald on HN
Needs a designer and better visuals with food photos
From 3 comments
You need to hire a designer for this. Cooking/recipes/food markets are really visually driven. You also need to define what a fork is right on the landing page. A fork for a cook…
orangethirty on HNYou should remove all of the pictures that do not show the food and replace all of the low quality pictures as well. When I went to your website the first thing i saw was a bunch…
6thSigma on HNI find it waaaay too geeky for a cooking website. The idea could be useful but as it is right now, it's very hard to understand how it's supposed to work. (Revision 2, what?)
d0m on HN
Too geeky for a cooking website
From 1 comment
I find it waaaay too geeky for a cooking website. The idea could be useful but as it is right now, it's very hard to understand how it's supposed to work. (Revision 2, what?)
d0m on HN
Requests
Metric unit conversion
From 2 comments
Just like every other cool page for managing recipes: Please add automatic conversion from/to metric units.
the-kenny on HNI would use it if you built in conversions for us that think in deciliters and not spoons or lb. Ie a dropdown on the profile settings page.
pbjorklund on HN
Diff view that non-technical users can read
From 2 comments
From a quick browse, I don't see any way to view diffs?
cdr on HNThere actually is a really basic diff tool right now (Click on revisions on the recipe page). I'm working on creating a more advanced one now. Any ideas on what a good interface…
dpick on HN
Social login options
From 1 comment
Very nice! I'd like to have the option (but not the requirement) to log in with oauth(2) from Facebook, Google, Twitter, etc. Your site will get a lot more traction if you…
Turing_Machine on HN
Questions
How is the diff or revision history shown?
From 2 comments
this idea is awesome. The "forking" idea is great for recipes, but you need almost something like a difftool to be able to tell what's different and why? I think with a better UI…
jfaucett on HNFrom a quick browse, I don't see any way to view diffs?
cdr on HN
Alternatives named
Fork the Cookbook
From 1 comment
We launched Fork the Cookbook about the same time as Forking Recipes too. You might want to check it out: http://forkthecookbook.com We try not to call it Github for Recipes…
chewxy on HN
Cucumbertown
From 2 comments
Cucumbertown does this very well. They allow you to take a recipe and fork it – called “Write a variation” (on the left) [1]. IIRC quite a few recipes there are created this way.…
gingerjoos on HNhttp://www.cucumbertown.com does this very well. Cleaner UI and seamless experience. Also has a lot of celebrity chefs onboard as users.
cyriacthomas on HN
Forkinit
From 1 comment
[Forkinit](http://forkinit.com/) does a good job of this but hasn't been updated in a while. You might check them out for other ideas in this space. Looks like you have a great…
webology on HN