FindGitHubEmail
Security and privacy
email address lookup
SHOW HN2013
How HN took it
3 positive, 5 neutral or asking, 0 mixed, 4 critical, out of 12 comments about the project. Thread score 0.00.
Idea: 2 for, 2 againstExecution: 1 for, 2 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Useful tool, and email addresses are not secrets
From 1 comment
Thanks for the useful tool! Email addresses are not secrets, and I can't count the hours I've wasted trying to email some developer who thinks that by keeping his email address…
NelsonMinar on HN
Clever short bash script
From 1 comment
I'm always fascinated when something like this appears on HN and it turns out to be a dozen lines of bash. I could easily imagine writing a hundred lines of a "better" language…
tsm on HN
Objections
Emails are already public on GitHub profiles, so it adds little
From 2 comments
This feels like nothing more than linkbait with no value-add. Emails are public on Github anyways, so simply browsing to github.com/<username> will show the users registered…
hoop on HNPretty obvious to those of us who use GitHub. Commit to a public repo under your email and people can see it? Not news.
twistedpair on HN
Only finds users with public activity; misses private-org users
From 1 comment
Title should be corrected, as it doesn't get the email address of all users, only those with public activity. A team member on a private org repo I'm a part of has no public…
bdcravens on HN
Returns emails of other contributors rather than the user
From 1 comment
Running it against my username, the first email address it pulls is the email of someone who contributed to one of my projects, not mine. (using -a does also include my address)
bdcravens on HN
Harvested emails fuel recruiter spam
From 2 comments
You can get any email for a developer from their commits in the json api...companies like Entelo & TalentBin have discovered this a long time ago and appear to be reselling them…
bitsweet on HN> If you have seen an uptick in recruiter spam lately, now you know why. Thank you, I was wondering how so many managed to find my e-mail.
ceejayoz on HN
Requests
Use a better bash approach or other language
From 2 comments
It could be better bash, e.g. using [[ instead of [. Also, ``` curl -s https://api.github.com/users/$2/events/public | grep "\"gravatar_id\":" | sed -e's/[,|"]//g' | head -n 1 |…
ralph on HNRuby uses `` to execute installed programs, which is the best part of bash. I'd say Ruby rivals bash in this sense.
nsmartt on HN
Use MD5 matching against gravatar hash
From 2 comments
I thought this was going to be a reverse-MD5 on their gravatar url. Interesting to know this is there, too! (As a possible improvement you could also take all possible matches…
adamsmith on HNhttps://github.com/hodgesmr/FindGitHubEmail/pull/5 I'm not really that familiar with bash scripting so this might be a mess.
bcuccioli on HN
Questions
Why is this news on Hacker News?
From 1 comment
Honest question - why is this news? (And why was it also news yesterday?)
scoot on HN
Is it legal to email harvested addresses under CAN-SPAM?
From 3 comments
You can get any email for a developer from their commits in the json api...companies like Entelo & TalentBin have discovered this a long time ago and appear to be reselling them…
bitsweet on HN> I believe its illegal (can-spam) to email someone if you harvested their email programmatically Nope. You can email pretty much anyone in America, regardless of how you…
eli on HNThe CAN-SPAM Act has specific prohibitions (and extra harsh sentencing guidelines) for spamming harvested (or "dictionary attack") e-mails. Even if you meet all the other…
dangrossman on HN
Alternatives named
Entelo and TalentBin harvest developer emails from commits
From 1 comment
You can get any email for a developer from their commits in the json api...companies like Entelo & TalentBin have discovered this a long time ago and appear to be reselling them…
bitsweet on HN
Hacktalent sells developer emails
From 1 comment
$500... http://hacktalent.com sells them for $9
welder on HN