Kraken.io
Web and SaaS
image optimization service
SHOW HN2013
How HN took it
6 positive, 17 neutral or asking, 6 mixed, 12 critical, out of 41 comments about the project. Thread score -0.07.
Performance: 1 for, 5 againstIdea: 2 for, 3 againstExecution: 1 for, 3 againstPricing: 1 for, 1 againstDesign: 1 for, 0 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Clean, polished website and design
From 3 comments
The website looks extremely professional, very well done.
stephanos2k on HNMy quick 5 minute review of this site is: nice work. The design and feel of the site itself is very polished and professional. I threw a handful of "optimized" images at it, and…
JeremyMorgan on HNNice site. I found 5% savings on about 40kb. Every little helps. It's fantastic that you've made a free web interface, but it would be great if we could enter a URL and it would…
deanclatworthy on HN
Fast, easy upload and real-time savings progress
From 2 comments
Very nicely done, kraken-io! Just threw over 500 images at it (mainly PNGs, but a few JPGs and GIFs as well), virtually all of which I had optimized beforehand. For the PNGs, I…
miles on HNI am very impressed with the website design and the well thought through and fast user interface. It seemed to be able to gain around 5% in average. This is not useful for me…
kken on HN
Useful for reducing image sizes on web pages
From 1 comment
Excellent news! I work for a very large publisher in Canada that uses WordPress as its CMS of choice. Because we use Akamai and shrug at bandwidth costs, I don't have much of an…
yllus on HN
Objections
Per-image pricing is unfavourable for large or varied image counts
From 3 comments
I like it. I had the same idea - not that it's a difficult idea to have. Well executed. However, I have some criticism. > We like to think the only way to get your image files…
pdknsk on HNMy quick 5 minute review of this site is: nice work. The design and feel of the site itself is very polished and professional. I threw a handful of "optimized" images at it, and…
JeremyMorgan on HNI'd love to see a pay as you go option. I run a SaaS where the user can select a profile picture, however, we usually get users with 100-150 at a time, then maybe nothing for a…
oellegaard on HN
8MB max file size is too small
From 2 comments
Very nice website and service, only thing I found an issue with was the max file size - 8MB. This is very small. Imagine if someone wanted to take a bunch of photos straight out…
thejosh on HNI'm building a service right now that is a community site for people in the fashion photography (photographers/models/etc) world. The images that these people upload are…
bradleyjoyce on HN
Savings are small compared to local free tools
From 3 comments
> For the PNGs, I had used 4 different optimizers (PNGCrush, OptiPNG, AdvPNG, and PNGOut), but almost all images saw size reductions in lossless mode ranging from under 1% to…
rorrr2 on HNAnd don't have to transmit your images over the net.. and.. and... Frankly, I don't understand how anyone would want to pay USD 250 per year to get a service which albeit behind…
radiospiel on HNWell, there's where the problem is. I want to do a clean build on each deploy, and there will be many devs on many machines building it, so handling it locally isn't really…
pbiggar on HN
Metadata stripping removes copyright info and colour profiles
From 2 comments
I really like the service but PLEASE please do not strip all metadata out of photos uploaded by your users. Stripping out the EXIF/IPTC copyright information creates an orphan…
hopeless on HNI tried quickly with a PNG screenshot, and found that the result was bigger than what ImageOptim could do. It seems to me that you're not stripping color profile information, you…
agos on HN
Testimonials look fake
From 1 comment
I like it. I had the same idea - not that it's a difficult idea to have. Well executed. However, I have some criticism. > We like to think the only way to get your image files…
pdknsk on HN
Requests
WordPress plugin
From 3 comments
1. How does it compare to JPEGmini? 2. You need a (good) Wordpress plugin.
Sujan on HNI second the WordPress plugin idea - I've got a few clients I'd sign up (probably only on the micro 500/month sized plan).
bigiain on HNWe are developing our official WP plugin at the moment. We are bound to have something to show in the 1-2 weeks from now.
kraken-io on HN
Pay-as-you-go pricing
From 1 comment
I'd love to see a pay as you go option. I run a SaaS where the user can select a profile picture, however, we usually get users with 100-150 at a time, then maybe nothing for a…
oellegaard on HN
Larger file size limit
From 2 comments
Very nice website and service, only thing I found an issue with was the max file size - 8MB. This is very small. Imagine if someone wanted to take a bunch of photos straight out…
thejosh on HNI'm building a service right now that is a community site for people in the fashion photography (photographers/models/etc) world. The images that these people upload are…
bradleyjoyce on HN
Caching for automated build pipelines
From 1 comment
This looks great! How would I use this as part of an asset pipeline? If I'm running it as part of an automated process, I'd love to see prices that support that model, as well as…
pbiggar on HN
Downloadable local app
From 1 comment
Thanks for the reply. As someone being into photography I would like to have the functionality that kraken provides on my local machine; even saving 10% on my huge pile of…
radiospiel on HN
Questions
How does it compare to JPEGmini and TinyPNG?
From 2 comments
What would be the difference from tools like http://tinypng.org and http://www.jpegmini.com/main/shrink_photo ?
mva on HN1. How does it compare to JPEGmini? 2. You need a (good) Wordpress plugin.
Sujan on HN
Is PCI DSS compliance verified?
From 2 comments
Do you have PCI DSS certification ? The credit card number is going through your servers.
prattbhatt on HNHow does wirecard verify your PCI DSS? It's usually a SAQ and pen scans.
Uchikoma on HN
Could large uploads be used for denial of service?
From 2 comments
Just had a thought. If I generate 8MB PNG files with noise in them and upload 1000 of such files, your servers will choke. Maybe you should charge per MB.
rorrr2 on HNNo, I mean it can be used to DoS you. Give it a try. Optimizing even one 8MB noise PNG is a huge amount of CPU work.
rorrr2 on HN
Alternatives named
ImageOptim
From 1 comment
http://imageoptim.com/ Similarly you can get some pretty good optimisations with the local, and open source OSX app, which is itself just a frontend for free linux utilities.
nwh on HN
JPEGmini
From 2 comments
What would be the difference from tools like http://tinypng.org and http://www.jpegmini.com/main/shrink_photo ?
mva on HNExactly what I was thinking. JPEGmini works better in my tests.
wijnglas on HN
TinyPNG
From 1 comment
What would be the difference from tools like http://tinypng.org and http://www.jpegmini.com/main/shrink_photo ?
mva on HN
Smushit
From 1 comment
Surprised no one has mentioned Yahoo!'s smushit.com service yet. It even works nearly identically (minus the API). Kraken seems to do a tad better in the handful of images I…
chrismeller on HN