Murder Board
Web and SaaS
idea feedback marketplace
SHOW HN2015
How HN took it
1 positive, 2 neutral or asking, 0 mixed, 5 critical, out of 8 comments about the project. Thread score -0.40.
Idea: 1 for, 3 againstDesign: 0 for, 1 againstPricing: 0 for, 1 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Real names on the site make it more credible
From 1 comment
Nice idea. I was skeptical at first until looking through the site, the sample reports, and seeing that you use real names on the site. Good luck with it!
natch on HN
Objections
Reviewers lack domain expertise to judge ideas
From 1 comment
Conceptually this sounds interesting but I feel almost no one is truly qualified to judge an idea unless you are an expert in that specific field and even then i'm hesitant to…
source99 on HN
Pricing is steep, around $250 per report
From 2 comments
somewhat needed idea but crazy steep pricing IMO
vishalzone2002 on HNI think if you are taking $250 from people you should sign an NDA. From http://murder-board.com/faq#group_367 "Will you sign an NDA?" The sheer number of NDAs we would have to be…
skmurphy on HN
Refuses to sign NDAs despite taking paid fees
From 1 comment
I think if you are taking $250 from people you should sign an NDA. From http://murder-board.com/faq#group_367 "Will you sign an NDA?" The sheer number of NDAs we would have to be…
skmurphy on HN
Red color scheme feels less trustworthy
From 2 comments
Good Luck. But all that redness in the site makes me trust you guys less. You guys need to change the color scheme which oozes out more welcoming and trustworthy feeling.
YogeeKnows on HNYeah get the murder part. Try more white and little red peeking. Too much red = Blood Bath and Some novice Killer on loose. Little Red = Well planned and well executed murder…
YogeeKnows on HN
Free HN already gives critical feedback
From 1 comment
Why use this site when HN will gladly tear apart your app/idea for free?
swang on HN
Requests
Change the red color scheme to something more welcoming
From 1 comment
Good Luck. But all that redness in the site makes me trust you guys less. You guys need to change the color scheme which oozes out more welcoming and trustworthy feeling.
YogeeKnows on HN
Sign an NDA for paid clients
From 1 comment
I think if you are taking $250 from people you should sign an NDA. From http://murder-board.com/faq#group_367 "Will you sign an NDA?" The sheer number of NDAs we would have to be…
skmurphy on HN
Questions
Why use this instead of free HN feedback
From 1 comment
Why use this site when HN will gladly tear apart your app/idea for free?
swang on HN
Alternatives named
Hacker News threads for free feedback
From 1 comment
Why use this site when HN will gladly tear apart your app/idea for free?
swang on HN