The On1on
Productivity
satire news site
SHOW HN2013
How HN took it
6 positive, 8 neutral or asking, 4 mixed, 26 critical, out of 44 comments about the project. Thread score -0.37.
Execution: 0 for, 14 againstIdea: 3 for, 5 againstDesign: 2 for, 6 against
The thread, comment by comment
Each row is a top-level comment and its replies, in HN's order. Select a cell to open that comment on HN.
positive neutral or mixed critical about another commenter or something else the maker
What HN said
What people liked
Idea is funny and clever
From 3 comments
Hmm I was confused when I saw actual articles from The Onion on there, but that's because the top navigation links point to pages on The Onion. Aside from that minor confusion,…
hansy on HNExcellent! This reminds me of "Daily Rotten News".
tlogan on HNhaha yes
jdolitsky on HN
Science/Tech tab design is good
From 1 comment
The Science/Tech header tab is great.
duggieawesome on HN
Objections
Hotlinking The Onion's CSS and resources is bad practice
From 3 comments
Um, are you seriously hotlinking to resources hosted by theonion.com? That is a terrible, terrible idea. ``` <link rel="stylesheet"…
sp332 on HNBecause if the onion goes down, so does your site. Because the onion can take the link down just to mess with you. Because the onion gets owned, or feels like it, they can have…
taproot on HNBesides what everyone else said, hotlinking other people's resources has been considered bad form since the early days of the Web, and its legality is questionable as well.
chc on HN
Copied fonts and CSS may infringe copyright
From 3 comments
Hi. I actually work as a developer at The Onion. Given the conversation we just had, I'd say that it seems like you're not in "our circles". Honestly, I think this idea is pretty…
csinchok on HNRegarding fonts: it's not the Onion you really have to worry about, but the actual owner of the fonts. That's who is going to come after you for copyright infringement.
sp332 on HNI get that this was rushed, etc. But it's not like you did a soft launch to test this thing out, or that you're on some kind of deadline here. You built the site lazily and…
csinchok on HN
Name and look too close to The Onion, trademark risk
From 3 comments
I'm not sure the I'd go with the name "The On1on". It seems too close to trademark infringement. An alternative off the top of my head is "The Un-ion" (as in "un-" + "Onion") but…
networked on HNI'm not ok with this. Watch the trademark. I'm not even talking about litigation -- just not ok with people willing to trade on another company's name.
snoonan on HNHopefully theonion appreciates the homage, this is fairly textbook trademark infringement and they can take this domain away.
wilfra on HN
Top navigation links point to the real Onion, confusing
From 2 comments
You should fix the top links (Video, Politics, Sports, Business, Science, Tech, Entertainment, and Breaking) so that they don't take you to the real Onion.
jaredsohn on HNWhy do the links take me to the actual onion site? Let's say I visit your site. Then I am viewing real news that looks fake (i.e. just poor and sensationalist journalism). But…
rckrd on HN
Requests
Change the name to avoid trademark issues
From 2 comments
I'm not sure the I'd go with the name "The On1on". It seems too close to trademark infringement. An alternative off the top of my head is "The Un-ion" (as in "un-" + "Onion") but…
networked on HNA visual nottheonion is a great idea. I suggest changing the name to something that's not going to violate their trademark. Also, a quick way to avoid hot-linking the images is…
mmahemoff on HN
Stop hotlinking CSS and images
From 2 comments
Well, the big concern is that those look like cache files, which means they could just go away at any second. In the rush to launch I didn't care, but I should be more careful /…
slifty on HNFor the record this was an oversight in the rush to get this out ASAP -- I'm correcting it now (thanks for calling it out!)
slifty on HN
Fix top navigation links to avoid the real Onion
From 2 comments
You should fix the top links (Video, Politics, Sports, Business, Science, Tech, Entertainment, and Breaking) so that they don't take you to the real Onion.
jaredsohn on HNThe Video, Politics, Sports, Business and Entertainment links point to theonion.com. I suggest that you change this. An Onion dev already posted that he had considered screwing…
a_p on HN
Remove the sharing links
From 2 comments
You may want to rid of those sharing links: http://i.imgur.com/3EYKseY.jpg Generally those are more harm than they're worth, as nobody uses them and they annoy the user…
stevenleeg on HNNoted, and removed in the next push.
slifty on HN
Questions
Why is hotlinking a bad idea
From 1 comment
Why is it a terrible idea?
marssaxman on HN
Alternatives named
/r/nottheonion
From 1 comment
I was going to suggest /r/nottheonion but it seems OP is already using it. Not bad though, I kinda like it. EDIT: oops, you're OP. Ever thought of suggesting this CSS to reddit?
chewxy on HN
Daily Rotten News
From 1 comment
Excellent! This reminds me of "Daily Rotten News".
tlogan on HN
News of the Weird
From 1 comment
This site reminds me of "News of the Weird": http://www.newsoftheweird.com/archive/index.html
greenyoda on HN
Fark
From 1 comment
Cool. It's like http://www.fark.com/ but with a more attractive layout.
cpdean on HN